045: Right Place, Right Time

In This Episode: Sure, being in the right place at the right time helps. But it often takes Uncommon Sense to step back to consider the bigger picture, and what the implications of a profound event might be. This is the story of how someone I knew as a young man did just that, but rather than take advantage and get rich, he leveraged his luck to help millions. It’s an amazing story.

045: Right Place, Right Time

Jump to Transcript

How to Subscribe and List of All Episodes

Show Notes

  • To help support Uncommon Sense, see the Patron’s Page, or the form in the sidebar.
  • The Parkinson’s Institute that Dr. Langston founded still exists. Their web site is here. The Michael J. Fox Foundation is here.
  • The update of Dr. Langston and Jon Palfreman’s book came out in 2014: The Case of the Frozen Addicts: How the Solution of a Medical Mystery Revolutionized the Understanding of Parkinson’s Disease.
  • The full 1986 episode of Nova about Dr. Langston can be viewed online at WGBH Boston.
  • Photos of Dr. Langston are included in the transcript below.


Welcome to Uncommon Sense. I’m Randy Cassingham.

On July 16, 1982, a heroin addict was rushed to Santa Clara, California’s, Valley Medical Center from the county jail. He hadn’t overdosed, but rather he was completely frozen, and the medics, let alone the jailers, couldn’t understand what was wrong. George Carillo couldn’t move or speak. He was admitted to the hospital, and the neurologist on call was J. William Langston — he and his wife, Lisa, happened to be my parents’ next-door neighbors.

Dr. Langston was just as perplexed by George’s condition. He had been fine the day before, but now he was stiff and unmoving. Sounds a lot like severe Parkinson’s disease, the doctor eventually decided, and he gave George the classic drug to treat Parkinson’s, L-dopa. Sure enough, almost instantly George was able to move and talk again. As the drug wore off, he was again frozen. Sadly, as in the case of regular Parkinson’s disease, the L-dopa became less and less effective over time.

carillo heroin - 045: Right Place, Right Time
Mr. Carillo could still write, and that’s how he was able to answer Dr. Langston’s questions. Clearly his mental ability was unimpaired, just like with “natural” Parkinson’s. Note the clue toward the bottom middle: he admitted he used “herion”. (Photo courtesy Dr. J. William Langston)

Parkinson’s disease is a long-term degenerative disorder of the central nervous system which usually, but not always, hits older people, and affects the motor system. It starts with a very subtle weakness, and leads to uncontrollable shaking, rigidity, slow movements, and difficulty in walking. Treatments help, but they don’t stop the disease, and it continually gets worse as time passes. Around 10 million people worldwide are affected, and each year around 125,000 of them die early due to Parkinson’s. The disease is named for the English doctor James Parkinson, who first described what he was seeing in detail in a paper published in 1817, and at that time it was an essentially new disease, which I’ll get back to in a few minutes.

“Back to the Future” actor Michael J. Fox has been very public about his struggles with Parkinson’s for more than 20 years, which has definitely helped increase awareness, and points out that yes, it can hit young people too: he was just 29 when he was diagnosed. More recently, actor Alan Alda, best known as Hawkeye Pierce on the TV series M*A*S*H, announced he also has the disease. He’s more typical: it surprised me when I looked him up: he’s now 83 years old.

Anyway, as Dr. Langston discovered and cared for more and more instant-Parkinson’s heroin addicts — six, in total — he eventually pieced together what happened: the addicts had been sold so-called “designer” heroin, made in a clandestine laboratory. The guy was trying to make (take a deep breath) 1-Methyl-4-phenyl-4-propionoxypiperidine, a synthetic opioid drug, which understandably goes by the easier to remember (and say!) name, MPPP.

Dr. Langston got a sample of this poorly made drug and sent it out for analysis. It took a long time to get the results and it’s a convoluted story, but he and his colleagues eventually figured out that the home chemist didn’t do it quite right: the MPPP was contaminated with (take another deep breath) 1-methyl-4-phenyl-1,2,3,6-tetrahydropyridine, or MPTP, which sounds close, but is wildly different.

They eventually figured out that MPTP is a neurotoxin, and it destroys the same area in the brain that Parkinson’s does. But instead of taking years or decades to do that, by being injected into the bloodstream it happens in hours.

And here’s where Bill Langston’s Uncommon Sense really kicked in: he realized that if there was a chemical that could create Parkinson’s disease downright instantaneously, researchers could do it with lab animals so they could make much more rapid advances in treating the disease in humans. Bill founded the Parkinson’s Institute to speed up the study of the disease, and how to stop it. He said later that with this discovery, for the first time, “we had ways to study why cells die in Parkinson’s disease.” And with that, “We could test new medicines as fast as you could make them.”

Later, when Michael J. Fox created his own foundation to help advance the study of Parkinson’s, there wasn’t competition, there was collaboration: Bill was a founding member of its Scientific Advisory Board. Fox says that Bill was “the guy responsible for getting me pumped up about the science behind PD research — and the challenges we could take on.” So much so that the Fox Foundation’s annual award, established in 2006, is called the J. William Langston Award.

If this story sounds familiar somehow, you might remember the PBS TV science series Nova, which started in 1974 and is still running today. Back in those days, Nova was quite a good program, not the “gee-whiz let’s tell this story like it’s the end of the world” style it uses today.

bill langston 300x203 - 045: Right Place, Right Time
A screen grab from the Nova episode with Dr. Langston: two of the six patients he worked with in this case were women. (Photo: WGBH)

In 1986, Nova did an episode on Bill Langston and the remarkable breakthroughs enabled by his figuring out what was going on, and how that botched home-made heroin could be used to speed up research into Parkinson’s. It was titled “The Case of the Frozen Addict”. The episode was so successful that in 1992, Nova did a second episode to follow up on the story.

In the opening I mentioned that rather than do something to get rich off this situation, Dr. Langston leveraged it to help others. But “could he” have gotten rich? Well, someone sure did. Once the researchers finally figured out it that MPTP was the culprit, they were able to get some pure MPTP from a company who actually made it — on purpose (more on that in a moment). That company was selling small jars of the stuff for just a few dollars. Understanding what was going on, they provided Dr. Langston with a pretty big jar — it was so cheap to make they just gave it to them.

Yet as news started breaking that the MPTP would enable studies to help learn more about Parkinson’s disease, they jacked up the price. Double? Triple? Don’t be silly: more than 800 times the original price! Bill said that just the leftover MPTP in the jar they gave him, after all their testing, would cost more than $200,000 — and that was in the mid-1980s! In today’s dollars, that’s nearly a half million. Doesn’t that give you an idea as to just one reason medical research is so expensive?

And there are a couple of other wild twists: Nova’s 1986 episode was written, produced, and directed by Jon Palfreman. It was such a hit that he and Dr. Langston turned it into a book with a lot more detail. It was released in 1995, and reissued with updates in 2014; I’ll link to it on the Show Page. Later, Jon Palfreman was diagnosed with, you guessed it, Parkinson’s. And the clandestine chemist who made the botched batch of heroin? He was identified and went to prison, and later — yep — he started to develop Parkinson’s disease due to his exposure to the MPTP that he accidentally made. He was able to go to his neurologist of choice: Bill Langston.

By applying a little Uncommon Sense to these facts, there’s a startling conclusion to be made: the amateur chemist didn’t use the drugs he made himself, but he still got Parkinson’s from handling it. And in fact, Bill learned there were several researchers who ended up with severe Parkinson’s from doing research on MPTP. Did Jon Palfreman get Parkinson’s because he was in some of the research labs when he was doing the filming, while MPTP was being tested? It’s impossible to know.

Yet that’s a sobering extension of Dr. Langston’s Uncommon Sense: as noted early in this episode, Parkinson’s disease wasn’t known to medical science before the early 19th century. Studies have proven that it’s not a genetic disease. It’s not caused by a virus. Rather, it’s something in the environment. And if the disease only showed up in modern times, it’s probably something that modern industry created that’s causing the disease.

But wait: why was that company making MPTP? Shockingly, Bill discovered that chemical companies had synthesized it decades before, and it was actually made available for sale as an herbicide. It wasn’t very effective, so it dropped out of use in favor of other similar compounds.

Think about that. Dr. Langston sure did! Parkinson’s is caused by some sort of environmental exposure, and MPTP and similar compounds have been and are being sprayed on crops as herbicides and pesticides. In the Nova episode, Bill said that “To the best of my knowledge, no one has done a methodical search in the environment looking for MPTP, or MPTP-like compounds.” The greater the human exposure, even just touching MPTP, like the researchers did in their laboratories, the faster that you or I will get Parkinson’s. Once the damage is done, it can’t be undone: there’s no fix, no cure, for Parkinson’s. To the best of my knowledge, it’s still true that no one has done a methodical search in the environment looking for MPTP, or MPTP-like compounds. Yet studies have shown that Parkinson’s is more prevalent in agricultural areas.

Let that sink in.

jw langston 266x300 - 045: Right Place, Right Time
Bill Langston, some years later. (Photo: Michael J. Fox Foundation)

I’m lucky enough to have had a number of people with Uncommon Sense in my life as informal mentors, including Bill, and I’ve absolutely benefitted from being around those people. I’m a very lucky guy to have had such great influences throughout my life: I’ve been in the right place at the right time myself — many times. And on many of those occasions I have taken the time to step back, and notice, and think about what’s going on. It’s something we can all do …if we notice and think about it.

For photos of Dr. Langston, who is apparently retired (I’ve lost contact with him over the years), plus a link to the 1986 entire Nova episode that you can watch online, and a place to comment on this episode, it’s all on the Show Page at thisistrue.com/podcast45

I’m Randy Cassingham … and I’ll talk at you later.

– – –

Bad link? Broken image? Other problem on this page? Let Me Know, and thanks.

This page is an example of Randy Cassingham’s style of “Thought-Provoking Entertainment”. His This is True is an email newsletter that uses “weird news” as a vehicle to explore the human condition in an entertaining way. If that sounds good, click here to open a subscribe form.

To really support This is True, you’re invited to sign up for a subscription to the much-expanded “Premium” edition:

One Year Upgrade

pixel - 045: Right Place, Right Time
(More upgrade options here.)

Q: Why would I want to pay more than the regular rate?

A: To support the publication to help it thrive and stay online: this kind of support means less future need for price increases (and smaller increases when they do happen), which enables more people to upgrade. This option was requested by existing Premium subscribers.

8 Comments on “045: Right Place, Right Time

  1. It is amazing to me how many gifted people populate this earth. This story gave me goose bumps. And extended my knowledge of Parkinson’s. Thanks Randy!

    I’ve been very lucky to meet so many interesting people, and realize there are SO many more out there! -rc

  2. Ok, you twisted my arm, so I read it. Very interesting, and absolutely unsurprising. I’ve had a couple of Parkinson patients on my massage table. One was a hairdresser, so I wonder if any of that stuff could have been in the products she worked with. Think of the things they put on food crops…. It’s a wonder we don’t all have it.

  3. Amazing, just amazing story about Dr. Langston. It certainly makes me think about my Mom. She developed a Benign Essential Tremor that developed similarly to Parkinson’s Disease (she did not have PD). I wonder if there’s a similar compound that she was exposed to?

  4. I just wanted to say that the transcript for the podcast was beautifully written and I enjoyed reading it.

    And thank you for providing a transcript! I don’t like listening to podcasts, but I do enjoy a well written, interesting piece, and this podcast on Parkinson’s was certainly both!

    I appreciate your kind words, and you’re most welcome! -rc

  5. OMG, is there anything that can be done about the blatant profiteering that company that makes MPTP did? And why doesn’t anyone else make it? If it’s so old, surely its patent has expired?

    I would think that others could make it, and others probably did. My guess is that they raised it so much because they had some available and either wanted to cash in before someone else made some, and/or didn’t really want to make more and cashed in because they were going to be the only source for some period of time. If it was ever patented, it was definitely expired by that point. -rc

  6. Thanks for telling this story about Dr. Langston. Our environment is in a state of continuous change. Knowledge often leads to meaningful actions.

  7. Makes me wonder about agent orange used in Vietnam and the correlation with PD? Or undertakers and formaldehyde?

    And if not PD specifically, what other diseases could be explained by such chemical exposure? -rc


Leave a Comment